MATHEMATICS FRAMEWORK
FOR CALIFORNIA PUBLIC SCHOOLS
KINDERGARTEN THROUGH GRADE TWELVE
DRAFT
SEPTEMBER 5, 1997
CHAPTER XI -- PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
Every student of mathematics deserves to be taught by a teacher who has both the mathematical knowledge and teaching skills needed to implement this Framework at that student=s level. The teacher must strive to convey mathematics in ways that allow students to experience the excitement and joy of doing mathematics. Such teachers are a precious resource that must be nurtured at all levels. Students who love mathematics must be recruited into the profession and then supported through preservice preparation and inservice education. They must be helped in learning mathematics and in developing their own teaching styles so that they can implement a curriculum that balances problem solving, conceptual understanding, and mathematical skills. California=s teachers deserve the best possible support in this endeavor.
Given the shortage of highly trained mathematics teachers in California, schools and undergraduate institutions must actively encourage talented mathematics students to go into teaching careers. Undergraduate internships in K-12 classrooms, followed up with guided reflection and discussion, can be effective recruitment tools and enhance the value of credential year study.
A. Preservice
Undergraduate Preparation
Teachers need mathematical backgrounds considerably deeper and broader than the mathematics they are expected to teach. They need this to understand the place of what they teach in the long-term curriculum and to be able to see where their students= thinking might lead. Teachers= mathematical breadth should enable them to understand interrelationships of mathematical ideas across strands, as, for example, subdivision of rectangles and multiplication strategies. Teachers= mathematical depth should enable them to understand the dependence of mathematical ideas upon one another, as, for example, adding fractions in algebra depends on adding fractions in arithmetic, which, in turn, depends on common denominators, and these depend on common multiples. It is not enough for teachers merely to be able to motivate their students or check whether or not students are executing a procedure correctly.
K-6 teachers need a command of the mathematics described in this Framework for Algebra I, Geometry, and Algebra II. Further, prior to a credential program, K-6 teaching candidates should have a full year of mathematics content courses that cover at least the material described in Appendix B.
Junior high or middle school mathematics teachers need a command of mathematics beyond that of K-6 teachers. Prior to a credential program, junior high/middle school mathematics teachers should have a least 24 semester hours of courses that are part of an approved K-12 mathematics credential program.
High school mathematics teachers need the full background required for state secondary certification in mathematics before entering a credential program. College and university mathematics departments should design their programs so that their majors do not encounter unnecessary obstacles in meeting the state requirements.
Credential Year
In addition to mathematics content courses, preservice teachers at all levels need a broad understanding of pedagogical issues in mathematics. They need experiences/courses that enable them to
relate well to young people, create a positive classroom atmosphere, and help their students develop attitudes and study skills conducive to learning mathematics
understand issues of student development and how they influence learning
use effective questioning skills to guide and challenge students= thinking and enhance communication of mathematics
use varied classroom techniques in ways likely to enhance the learning of students with diverse backgrounds and learning styles
use a variety of assessment techniques, recognizing their value for various purposes including teaching decisions
use instructional tools, including paper and pencil, manipulatives, calculators, and computers, appropriately and effectively
communicate effectively with families and involve them in support of their students learning in positive, effective ways
A Special Note about the Shortage of Qualified Teachers
The shortage of qualified mathematics teachers affects primary and secondary schools in different ways. At the primary level there exist teachers who possess multiple subject credentials that do not meet the new demands of the curriculum in mathematics. Although these teachers may be highly effective in other areas and contribute to the overall program at their schools, they should be encouraged to turn to mathematically qualified colleagues for help in strengthening their own mathematics instruction.
At the junior high or middle school and at the high school levels, it is not uncommon for teachers to preside over mathematics classes that they are not certified to teach. Such teachers are granted emergency credentials through a process that is based in local school districts and is largely outside the credentialing process.
To deal with these very different problems, three steps are recommended:
1. At the primary level, the Commission on Credentialing should establish a special Mathematics Supplement to the multiple subject credential. This supplement is to be examination-based and correspond to a form of ìboard certificationî in mathematics for primary school teachers. With such a supplement in place, efforts should be made to maximize the number, but at least 20 percent of teachers at every primary school should have achieved this form of certification in mathematics, and all students at least once in their primary years should be assigned to their classes.
2. A special credential should be created to qualify teachers to teach mathematics no more advanced that Algebra I. The requirements for this special credential should be determined by the Commission on Teacher Credentialing, which should modify the mathematics requirements for the supplementary authorization in mathematics, if necessary, to make them the same as those for the new credential. The requirements for both programs should include courses in geometry, number theory, combinatorics or discrete mathematics, probability or statistics, and calculus. A teacher with this special credential or supplementary authorization would be automatically certified to teach mathematics in junior high and middle schools. Upon completion of the remainder of an approved program in mathematics, such teachers would automatically have their teaching certificates upgraded to all of K-12 mathematics.
3. Districts should require all teachers who do not have an appropriate credential to pass a rigorous test on the material they are supposed to teach before granting them an emergency credential. Failure to pass the test should be recognized as an acceptable reason for seeking to hire a more knowledgeable teacher for the class in question.
B. Inservice
Ongoing professional development should be expected of all teachers. Professional development for immediate classroom application should take place locally on a regular basis. Teachers should also be involved in long-term professional development of their mathematical knowledge and skills.
Professional Development and Retention of New Teachers
All too often new teachers ìwash outî in or just after their first year of teaching, thereby wasting much of the huge investment that went into their education. School administrators and colleagues must take steps to help new teachers succeed. Careful placement and active mentoring can help, as can activities listed below for all teachers. These can alleviate the isolation that can be a problem for all teachers but is most acute in the first year.
Local and Short-term Professional Development
Teachers within a given school or locality should meet together regularly to discuss content and pedagogy in the mathematics curriculum. They should be encouraged to set up an ongoing collegial support system like those that have been identified with successful mathematics programs. The focus of such collegial meetings would be to share successful lessons and teaching approaches and to coach one another in ways to improve student understanding. School and district administrations should support such in-house efforts by making time and space available for them.
Formal local inservice programs, including School Improvement Program (SIP) days, should address the needs of teachers involved. Further, teachers should be active participants in planning and organizing meetings, short courses, and workshops offered by local districts, colleges, universities, and professional organizations. These programs need to be assessed independently to determine their effectiveness.
C. Long-Term Professional Development
The goal of long-term professional development is sustained intellectual growth of mathematics teachers and enhancement of their mathematical knowledge and skill. Long-term professional development of this type should be expected and actively encouraged and rewarded both by school administrators and by state and national efforts. Institutions of higher education and other institutions with sufficient expertise should be enlisted in an effort to make opportunities for high-quality, long-term professional development available to all mathematics teachers. Long-term professional development programs in mathematics should be externally assessed to ensure that they achieve their goals of enhanced mathematical knowledge and capability. Teachers should be encouraged to share the benefits of their long-term professional development efforts as appropriate with their colleagues in local inservice programs such as School Improvement Program (SIP) days. Teachers should also be encouraged to belong to appropriate national and local professional organizations.
Since professional development is essential to implementing the high standards defined by this Framework, a variety of issues should be considered when designing such activities. The following is not a check-off list of what should be done, nor is it exhaustive. Indeed, any particular focused and in-depth program may only be able to deal with a few issues each year. Districts need to think carefully about their own priorities in deciding how to balance these considerations.
Issues to Consider in Designing Professional Development Activities or Programs
!
Programs with lasting impact are usually long-term and locally based, with teachers playing a substantial role in planning and implementation. The program should receive regular feedback from teachers and be modified accordingly.!
Program activities should be structured to raise comfort levels about mathematics and to enable participants to develop enthusiasm for learning mathematics.!
Program participants need to discuss what it means to balance the learning of mathematical skills, conceptual understanding, and problem solving across different developmental levels.!
Teachers should be helped to provide students with learning experiences that build the bridge between concrete contexts and more abstract mathematical ideas.!
In order for California=s diverse population to succeed, programs need to help teachers and administrators, through inservice training and sharing, expand their understanding of student differences and of other cultures.!
Teachers require support in developing skills to meet diverse language and language development needs in a language-dependent mathematics curriculum.!
Parent involvement is critical to student success. Programs should help teachers develop various strategies to help parents help their children.!
Professional development programs should focus both on student learning and on instructional strategies.!
There needs to be discussion of mathematics-specific classroom management issues such as organizing, distributing, or collecting manipulatives and dealing with a high classroom noise level.!
Programs should allow time for teacher reflection on why certain lessons or project activities work well--for example, discussion of questions that stimulate student thinking or reviewing case studies, portfolios, etc.!
Programs should provide opportunities for teachers to consider strategies for cultivating study skills and fostering a positive attitude in their students.!
Teachers need to learn about various forms of assessment, including their uses and their limitations.!
When teachers return to school sites, they need time to discuss with peers how to implement concepts that may have been presented earlier.
Issues to Consider when Implementing New Curricula
!
Professional development needs to balance providing teachers a better sense of the ìbig pictureî of mathematics teaching and learning with providing teachers program specific information.!
Time needs to be devoted to looking at a single concept in depth and seeing how it develops across grade levels in the new curriculum.!
Phase-in strategies for new curricula must be considered carefully. Teachers should be provided the necessary support to implement new programs consistently and according to a given time line to maintain momentum in the change process.APPENDIX B
DESCRIPTION OF COURSES I AND II FOR PRESERVICE EDUCATION
Source: These descriptions are updates from Recommendations on the Mathematical Preparation of Teachers, prepared by the Committee on the Undergraduate Program in Mathematics, Washington, DC, Mathematical Association of America, 1983, pp. 9-15. As stated in the document cited, ìthe course descriptions in these recommendations are not intended to be complete course descriptions but rather to identify topics that are particularly important for teachers.
The course descriptions assume as prerequisites three years of college preparatory mathematics, including two years of algebra and one year of geometry, and demonstrated mastery of the basic skills of the K-7 mathematics curriculum as outlined in this Framework. The courses described below should provide preservice teachers with the mathematical knowledge and background necessary to implement a curriculum that balances mathematical skills, development of conceptual understanding, and problem solving. To that end, the courses should exemplify this balance.
Objectives of Both Courses
The objectives of these two courses should be to provide teachers with the ability to:
develop students= mathematical thinking and understanding by identifying activities that are related to the child=s environment and involve age appropriate versions of the mathematical concepts and principles usually taught in the elementary grades
identify questioning strategies that promote thinking, and use problem solving strategies appropriate to these grades (including guess and test, pattern and searches, models, related problems...) with applications in concrete and abstract settings.
recognize that partially grasped ideas are a natural part of the learning process, and learn to look closely at what students are really thinking, since students may often be able to answer a procedural question correctly but still have fundamental misunderstandings
identify examples in the child=s environment of simple geometric shapes and present problem-solving activities that make meaningful use of their properties
model spatial relations and develop activities that illustrate properties of geometric shapes using classroom objects and manipulatives
use estimation wherever appropriate, in particular to pose and select alternatives among responses
make appropriate use of manipulatives and technology (calculators, computers, Internet...) as instructional tools
use mathematical terminology and symbolism appropriately while working with elementary school children
discuss and write about mathematical ideas effectively, recognizing that communication skills are developed, deepened, and made more complete over time
Features Common to Both Courses
The courses should provide teachers with:
experience in expressing intuitive mathematical ideas verbally and in writing
C
understanding of problems presented in written form or verbally and translate them into appropriate mathematical languageappreciation of the importance of pattern and discovery
understanding of the appropriate use of algorithms and practice
knowledge of how mathematical concepts from different strands are related (e.g. how the placement of rectangles inside larger rectangles can provide ways for students to develop and understand multiplication procedures)
examples of the dependence of certain mathematical skills on others (e.g. the ability to add fractions depends on the knowledge of how to find common multiples)
appropriate historical material on the topics listed below, to be presented at the time these topics are introduced
Fundamental Mathematical Concepts I
The course provides prospective teachers with part of the background needed for teaching the content of the elementary mathematics program as outlined in this Framework, including the development of the whole number system, measurement, and geometry.
Topics
While there may be considerable variation in the topics selected to achieve the objectives the following are particularly suitable for inclusion in such a course:
1. Number: Prenumeration concepts (attributes, classification, ordering, patterns). Properties of joining, separating, and comparing sets, set equivalence, set inclusion, and the use of sets in problem solving (Venn diagrams, exhaustive listings). Base ten numeration system; place value and its relation to grouping in operations, models for each of four basic operations; properties of the basic operations, common error patterns in student computation with basic algorithms.
Divisibility; prime and composite numbers; infinitude of primes, divisibility rules for whole numbers through 11 (excluding seven), lowest common multiple, greatest common divisor, and relative primeness.
2. Measurement: Use of standard and nonstandard (paper clips, erasers, body measures...) units in measuring length, perimeter, area, capacity, volume, mass, weight, angle, time, temperature. Selection of units of measure and methods of estimation.
3. Geometry: Basic two- and three dimensional objects: line, plane, square, rectangle, parallelogram, rhombus, trapezoid, triangles (scalene, right, isosceles, and equilateral), circles, rectangular solids, cubes, prisms, cones, pyramids, and sphere. Their properties: parallelism, perpendicularity, congruence (not only triangle), similarity, symmetry, length, area, and volume in basic metric and standard units, angles and angle measurement, the effect of scale on surface and volume. Use of geoboards, paper folding, and other models in illustrating geometric concepts. Basic concepts and properties of geometric transformations. Contexts in which geometric concepts arise, use of their properties in meaningful, nontrivial problem solving situations.
Fundamental Mathematical Concepts II
This course focuses on the development of the real number system and its subsystems, probability, statistics, and basic computer concepts. The prerequisite is Fundamental Mathematical Concepts I.
Topics
While, as in the case of Fundamental Mathematical Concepts I, there may be considerable variation in the topics selected to achieve the objectives stated above, the following topics are particularly suitable for inclusion in such a course.
1. Numbers: Extension of whole numbers to integers, models for integers, four basic operations with integers, properties of integers (order, absolute value,...). Extension of integers to the rational numbers, positive and negative, in any form, such as fraction, decimal, or percent and conversion between any of these representations. The four basic operations with rational numbers. Ratio and proportion. Properties of rational numbers. Extension of the rational numbers to irrational numbers such as pi, certain square roots, the irrationality of the square root 2; Pythagorean Theorem and a proof; properties of real numbers, use of square roots of positive numbers in meaningful contexts; relationship of real numbers to geometry. The arithmetic mean of a set of numbers. Integer and simple fraction exponents of real numbers. Scientific notation.
2. Algebra: Variables and functions, how they arise in modeling the world around us. Substantiating whether or not a given number satisfies a given equation. Solutions of linear equations and inequalities. Use of the Cartesian plane to graph shapes and linear functions. Use of formulas to express quantitative relationships. Qualitative understanding of how graphs of functions over time tell a story.
3. Probability: Relative frequency experiments; methods of counting (tree diagrams, exhaustive listings, permutations, combinations); sample spaces; joint events, independent events, dependent events, complementary events. Basic properties of probability.
4. Statistics: Organization and presentation of data (line, circle, and bar graphs; stem and leaf plots); role of scales and possible bias in graphs, analysis of the observed distribution (mean, median, mode, range, variance, standard deviation, percentile, quartile). Meaning of population, sample, and random sample. Sampling as it applies to consumers of sample research literature.
5. Technology: Impact of computers on contemporary school mathematics curricula; nature of an algorithm; elementary programming; writing simple programs correlated to the elementary school curriculum; role of computing in mathematics.