Mathematically Correct
Reported Feb. 1, 1997

Choice of Math Programs Supported in Palo Alto
Battle Lines Erased?


Sprinkled throughout the pages of the Mathematically Correct website are references to the often bitter debate about math education that has continued for years in Palo Alto and resulted in the formation of the HOLD parents' group. Despite the clear dissatisfaction of parents, a drop in test scores, and substantial costs to parents for private mathematics instruction, a resolution to the conflict was not forthcoming.

Against this background of strife, recent events in Palo Alto carry a special significance. As reported in the Palo Alto Weekly (SCHOOLS: End may be near to math debate -- Board in agreement on parents' choice initiative, by Elizabeth Darling, Jan. 31, 1997), the local school board appears willing to support a request from parents to implement a choice of math programs in their middle schools. The article quotes the parents' request as saying:

"In an effort to better satisfy the diverse educational needs of middle school children, as well as to unify the parent and teacher communities, we propose that the district offer a direct-instruction team of choice at both middle schools beginning in September 1997"

There is no doubt that the implementation of a system that affords this choice will be a difficult process, and approval of such a plan is a long way from seeing a successful alternative in place in their district. However, events in Palo Alto have got to be seen as a step in the correct direction. No one is claiming that this move is as significant internationally as, say, a Middle-East peace accord. But, in the clash over mathematics education, what happens in Palo Alto is very important. Peace (and satisfied parents) in Palo Alto would be wonderful.